Discover the Ultimate Savory Delight: The Best Lobster Roll in Nantucket

...

Discover the best lobster roll in Nantucket! Freshly caught lobster served on a buttery roll - a must-try for seafood lovers.


When it comes to seafood, few dishes are as iconic as the lobster roll. And for those seeking the very best, there's no better place to find it than on the charming island of Nantucket. From the picturesque harbor views to the abundance of fresh seafood, Nantucket is a haven for foodies and seafood lovers alike. But when it comes to the best lobster roll on the island, there are a few standout contenders that simply can't be missed.

First up is The SeaGrille, a beloved local restaurant that has been serving up delicious seafood since 1991. Their lobster roll is a true masterpiece, featuring succulent chunks of fresh lobster meat tossed with just the right amount of mayo and served on a buttery toasted bun. But what really sets The SeaGrille's lobster roll apart is the addition of crispy bacon, which adds a salty crunch that perfectly complements the sweet lobster.

For those looking for a more upscale dining experience, the Galley Beach is the place to go. This elegant beachfront restaurant offers stunning ocean views and an impressive menu of fresh seafood, including their famous lobster roll. Made with only the finest ingredients, each bite of their lobster roll is bursting with flavor and perfectly balanced between the succulent lobster meat and the crunchy, buttery bread.

Another must-try spot for lobster roll aficionados is the iconic Lobster Trap. This family-owned restaurant has been a staple of Nantucket's dining scene since 1969, and their lobster roll is the stuff of legend. Made with generous portions of fresh lobster meat and served on a lightly toasted bun, this dish is simple yet utterly satisfying. And with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, the Lobster Trap is the perfect spot to enjoy a leisurely meal.

If you're looking for something a bit more casual, head to the Juice Bar for their famous lobster roll ice cream. Yes, you read that right – this beloved ice cream shop serves up a unique take on the classic lobster roll, featuring vanilla ice cream swirled with chunks of fresh lobster meat and a drizzle of caramel sauce. It may sound strange, but trust us – it's absolutely delicious.

No matter which spot you choose, one thing is certain – the lobster rolls on Nantucket are truly unparalleled. Whether you're a longtime fan of this classic dish or simply looking to try something new, there's no better place to indulge in this seafood delicacy than on this charming island paradise.


The Best Lobster Roll in Nantucket

The island of Nantucket

Nantucket is a small island off the coast of Massachusetts known for its picturesque beaches, quaint downtown area, and delicious seafood. The island has become a popular vacation destination for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life and indulge in fresh seafood while enjoying the island's natural beauty.

The history of the lobster roll

The lobster roll is a classic New England dish that has been around for over a century. It is believed to have originated in Connecticut in the 1920s, but it quickly spread throughout New England and became a staple on seafood menus. The traditional lobster roll consists of chunks of fresh lobster meat mixed with mayonnaise, celery, and seasonings, served on a toasted hot dog bun.

The debate over the perfect lobster roll

There is much debate among lobster roll enthusiasts over what makes the perfect lobster roll. Some prefer their lobster rolls with a minimal amount of ingredients, allowing the fresh lobster meat to shine through, while others prefer a more complex recipe with added spices and flavors.

The contenders for the best lobster roll in Nantucket

Nantucket is home to many seafood restaurants, each claiming to have the best lobster roll on the island. The contenders for the title of best lobster roll in Nantucket include The Lobster Trap, The Galley Beach, and Sayle's Seafood.

The Lobster Trap

The Lobster Trap is a local favorite, known for its fresh seafood and casual atmosphere. Their lobster roll is made with chunks of fresh lobster meat, mixed with a light mayo-based dressing and served on a buttery brioche bun. The Lobster Trap's lobster roll is simple yet flavorful and is a must-try for anyone visiting Nantucket.

The Galley Beach

The Galley Beach is a high-end restaurant located right on the beach, offering stunning views of the ocean while you dine. Their lobster roll is a bit more complex, featuring chunks of lobster meat mixed with a spicy aioli and served on a grilled brioche bun. The Galley Beach's lobster roll is a favorite among foodies and those looking for a more upscale dining experience.

Sayle's Seafood

Sayle's Seafood is a family-owned and operated seafood market and restaurant that has been serving fresh seafood to Nantucket locals and visitors for over 100 years. Their lobster roll is made with generous portions of fresh lobster meat, mixed with a light mayo dressing and served on a toasted hot dog bun. Sayle's Seafood's lobster roll is a classic New England-style lobster roll that is sure to satisfy any seafood lover.

The verdict

While each of these restaurants offers a delicious lobster roll, the title of best lobster roll in Nantucket goes to The Lobster Trap. Their simple yet flavorful recipe perfectly showcases the fresh lobster meat and the buttery brioche bun adds the perfect touch of sweetness. Whether you're a local or a visitor to Nantucket, you can't go wrong with a lobster roll from The Lobster Trap.
What Makes a Perfect Lobster Roll?A perfect lobster roll is not just a sandwich; it's an experience. A good lobster roll should have chunks of fresh, sweet lobster meat that are lightly seasoned and dressed with just enough mayonnaise to hold it all together. The roll should be buttered and toasted to perfection, and the overall flavor should be bright and fresh.The Best Places to Get a Lobster Roll in NantucketNantucket is known for its seafood, and the lobster roll is no exception. Here are some of the best places to get a lobster roll on the island:1. The Lobster Trap: This family-owned restaurant is located in the heart of Nantucket and serves up some of the freshest seafood on the island. Their lobster roll is a classic New England-style roll that is filled with succulent chunks of lobster meat and served on a buttered and toasted roll.2. The Galley Beach: This upscale restaurant is located right on the beach and offers stunning views of the ocean. Their lobster roll is made with fresh local lobster meat and is served on a brioche bun with a side of hand-cut fries.3. Slip 14: This casual waterfront restaurant is known for its seafood and has a great selection of lobster rolls to choose from. Their classic lobster roll is made with fresh lobster meat that is lightly dressed with mayo and served on a buttered and toasted roll.A Guide to Nantucket's Classic Lobster RollThe classic Nantucket lobster roll is a simple yet delicious sandwich that is perfect for a summer day. Here's how to make one:Ingredients:- 1 lb fresh lobster meat- 1/4 cup mayonnaise- 1 tbsp lemon juice- Salt and pepper to taste- 4 hot dog buns- Butter for toasting the bunsInstructions:1. In a large bowl, mix together the lobster meat, mayonnaise, lemon juice, salt, and pepper.2. Toast the hot dog buns in butter until they are golden brown.3. Divide the lobster mixture evenly among the buns.4. Serve immediately.The Secret to Making the Perfect Lobster RollThe secret to making the perfect lobster roll is all in the lobster meat. You want to use fresh, high-quality lobster meat that is sweet and tender. It's also important to not overdo it on the mayo or other ingredients, as you want the flavor of the lobster to shine through.Another key to a perfect lobster roll is toasting the bun. This gives the sandwich a nice crunch and adds another layer of flavor to the dish.Why Nantucket Lobster Rolls Are So SpecialNantucket lobster rolls are special because they use fresh, locally sourced lobster meat that is caught right off the coast of the island. This means that the lobster is incredibly fresh and has a sweet, delicate flavor that can't be replicated anywhere else.Additionally, Nantucket is known for its rich seafood heritage, and the lobster roll is the quintessential New England seafood dish. When you eat a lobster roll on Nantucket, you are experiencing a piece of the island's history and culture.The Evolution of the Nantucket Lobster RollThe lobster roll may be a classic New England dish, but it has evolved over time. In the early days, lobster rolls were made with just lobster meat, butter, and a toasted bun. However, over time, chefs started adding ingredients like mayo, celery, and herbs to the mix.Today, there are many different variations of the lobster roll, from classic New England-style rolls to spicy Cajun-inspired rolls. However, no matter what variation you choose, the lobster is always the star of the show.The Best Lobster Roll Toppings to Try in NantucketWhile a classic lobster roll is delicious on its own, there are some toppings that can take it to the next level. Here are some of the best lobster roll toppings to try in Nantucket:1. Boursin cheese: This creamy, garlic and herb-flavored cheese is the perfect complement to sweet lobster meat.2. Avocado: Adding sliced avocado to your lobster roll gives it a fresh, summery twist.3. Bacon: Everything is better with bacon, and lobster rolls are no exception. Crispy bacon adds a nice crunch and salty flavor to the sandwich.How to Pair Your Lobster Roll with the Perfect BeverageWhen it comes to pairing your lobster roll with the perfect beverage, there are a few things to keep in mind. First, you want to choose a drink that complements the flavors of the lobster roll, rather than overpowering them.Some good options include:1. White wine: A crisp, dry white wine like Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Grigio pairs well with the light, delicate flavor of the lobster.2. Beer: A light, refreshing beer like a pilsner or a wheat beer is a great choice for a hot summer day.3. Lemonade: For a non-alcoholic option, try pairing your lobster roll with a tall glass of ice-cold lemonade. The bright, citrusy flavor complements the sweetness of the lobster.The Ultimate Guide to Nantucket's Lobster Roll FestivalsIf you're a lobster roll lover, you won't want to miss Nantucket's annual Lobster Roll Festival. This event takes place every July and features some of the best lobster rolls on the island, as well as live music, games, and activities for the whole family.In addition to the Lobster Roll Festival, there are also several other events throughout the year that celebrate Nantucket's rich seafood heritage, including the Nantucket Seafood Festival and the Nantucket Oyster Festival.Tips for Finding the Best Lobster Roll Deals in NantucketIf you're looking to save some money on your lobster roll adventure in Nantucket, there are a few tips to keep in mind. First, look for happy hour specials at local restaurants, which often offer discounted prices on drinks and appetizers.You can also try visiting some of the more casual seafood shacks and food trucks on the island, which often have lower prices than sit-down restaurants.Finally, don't be afraid to ask locals for recommendations. They know the island best and can often point you towards the best deals and hidden gems.

The Best Lobster Roll in Nantucket: A Point of View

Introduction

Nantucket is known for its stunning beaches, unique boutiques, and, of course, its seafood. Visitors to the island often flock to the many seafood shacks that dot the coastline, each claiming to have the best lobster roll around. But which one truly reigns supreme? In this article, we'll take a closer look at the contenders, weighing the pros and cons of each to determine the best lobster roll in Nantucket.

The Contenders

Saltbox Kitchen

Saltbox Kitchen is a farm-to-table restaurant located in Nantucket's historic downtown district. Their lobster roll features fresh, locally sourced lobster meat served on a buttery brioche bun.

Straight Wharf Fish Store

Straight Wharf Fish Store is known for its fresh seafood and casual atmosphere. Their lobster roll is a classic New England-style creation, with large chunks of lobster meat tossed in mayo and served in a toasted hot dog bun.

Millie's

Located on Madaket Beach, Millie's offers stunning views and a laid-back vibe. Their lobster roll features succulent lobster meat served atop a homemade potato roll, with a side of crispy fries.

The Pros and Cons

When it comes to determining the best lobster roll in Nantucket, there are a few key factors to consider:

Price

  • Saltbox Kitchen: $28
  • Straight Wharf Fish Store: $22
  • Millie's: $26

Winner: Straight Wharf Fish Store

Lobster Quality

  • Saltbox Kitchen: Locally sourced, fresh lobster meat
  • Straight Wharf Fish Store: Large chunks of fresh lobster meat
  • Millie's: Succulent lobster meat

Winner: Straight Wharf Fish Store

Bun Quality

  • Saltbox Kitchen: Buttery brioche bun
  • Straight Wharf Fish Store: Toasted hot dog bun
  • Millie's: Homemade potato roll

Winner: Saltbox Kitchen

Sides

  • Saltbox Kitchen: Potato chips
  • Straight Wharf Fish Store: Coleslaw
  • Millie's: Fries

Winner: Millie's

The Verdict

After weighing the pros and cons of each contender, we've determined that the best lobster roll in Nantucket is...Straight Wharf Fish Store! With its large chunks of fresh lobster meat and reasonable price point, it's hard to beat. However, if you're looking for a more upscale experience, Saltbox Kitchen's buttery brioche bun and locally sourced lobster meat are sure to impress. And if you're craving stunning views and crispy fries to go with your lobster roll, Millie's is the place to be.


Conclusion: The Best Lobster Roll in Nantucket

Thank you for taking the time to read this article about the best lobster rolls in Nantucket. We hope that we have been able to provide you with some valuable information and insights into the local lobster roll scene.

As you can see, there are many different options available when it comes to finding the perfect lobster roll in Nantucket. Whether you prefer a classic roll with just a touch of butter or a more elaborate version with unique toppings and flavors, there is something for everyone here on this beautiful island.

If you're looking for a traditional lobster roll experience, we highly recommend heading over to the Lobster Trap. This iconic restaurant has been serving up delicious seafood since 1969, and their lobster rolls are some of the best around. With plenty of fresh lobster meat, a toasted bun, and just the right amount of seasoning, these rolls are truly a must-try.

For those who want to try something a little different, we suggest checking out the Slip 14 lobster roll. This roll features a spicy aioli sauce and is served with crispy fried onions, giving it a unique and delicious flavor. And if you're looking for a more upscale experience, the Galley Beach lobster roll is an excellent choice. Made with fresh, locally sourced lobster and served on a homemade brioche bun, this roll is sure to impress.

No matter which restaurant you choose, we encourage you to take your time and savor every bite of your lobster roll. After all, this is a special treat that you won't find just anywhere. And if you're lucky enough to be visiting Nantucket during the summer months, be sure to attend the annual Lobster Trap Chowder Contest – a fun and delicious event that celebrates all things lobster!

Finally, we would like to remind you that Nantucket is a beautiful and unique destination that offers much more than just lobster rolls. From its stunning beaches and historic architecture to its vibrant arts and culture scene, there is something here for everyone to enjoy. So why not plan your next vacation to Nantucket and experience all that this amazing island has to offer?

Thank you again for reading, and we hope to see you soon on the shores of Nantucket!


What do people also ask about the best lobster roll in Nantucket?

1. Where can I find the best lobster roll in Nantucket?

If you're looking for the best lobster roll in Nantucket, there are several places you can try:

  • The Lobster Trap
  • Saltbox Kitchen
  • Straight Wharf Fish Store
  • Something Natural

Each of these places has its own unique take on the classic lobster roll, so it's worth trying them all to see which one you like best.

2. What makes a great lobster roll?

A great lobster roll should have:

  1. Fresh, local lobster meat
  2. A lightly toasted, buttered bun
  3. Minimal ingredients (mayonnaise, lemon juice, salt, and pepper)
  4. A generous portion of lobster meat

Some people prefer their lobster roll with additional ingredients such as celery or herbs, but a classic lobster roll should be simple and let the flavor of the lobster shine through.

3. How much does a lobster roll cost in Nantucket?

The cost of a lobster roll in Nantucket can vary depending on where you go and the size of the roll. Generally, you can expect to pay anywhere from $20 to $30 for a lobster roll in Nantucket.

4. Is it worth it to splurge on a lobster roll in Nantucket?

If you're a seafood lover, then yes, it's definitely worth it to splurge on a lobster roll in Nantucket. The lobster is fresh and delicious, and the experience of enjoying a classic New England dish in such a beautiful setting is unforgettable.